The plastic bag with a kazoo and three stickers has a well-deserved reputation. It goes straight into the trash, usually before the guest gets home, and everyone knows it. Party favors do not have to be that.
The ones that work are the ones kids actually use. Something she puts on immediately, or sets on her nightstand, or comes back to the next day. Here are the options that consistently land well at sleepover parties.
Favors Kids Actually Use and Keep
Eye Mask
Soft, on-theme, and practical. Girls put them on immediately and wear them all night.
Mini Skincare Set
Lip balm, face mist, mini lotion. Perfect for spa-themed parties or older guests.
Personalized Journal
Add her name with a label maker or stamp. Pair it with a good pen and it becomes something she uses.
Nail Polish
One good color in a small bag. Simple, affordable, and always a hit with the 7 to 12 crowd.
Custom Candy Bar
Wrap a chocolate bar with custom paper. Free templates online, takes 20 minutes, looks impressive.
Photo Strip
Print a photo from the party and slide it into a kraft envelope. The most personal favor possible.
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
How to Budget for Favors Without Overspending
Favors do not need to be expensive to feel generous. Here is a simple guide to what works at different price points:
| Budget Per Guest | What to Include |
|---|---|
| Under $5 | One good item: a nail polish, a mini journal, or a custom candy bar. Simple and done. |
| $5–$10 | Two or three small items in a kraft bag: eye mask + lip balm + a treat. Feels like a real gift. |
| $10–$15 | A themed mini kit: spa set, movie night pouch, or personalized items with a treat. Very memorable. |
| $15+ | Custom tote bag with personalized items. Reserve for smaller guest lists where the budget makes sense. |
The "One Great Thing" Rule
Instead of filling a bag with small forgettable items, give each guest one genuinely good thing. A candle. A real journal. A charm bracelet kit. Something she would actually pick out herself.
This works especially well for older girls, 10 and up, who have fully outgrown plastic trinkets. One item she loves will mean more than five things she does not care about.
Favors That Double as Party Activities
Some of the best favors are things the girls make or use during the party, so they serve as both an activity and a takeaway they are already attached to:
- Friendship bracelets they make at a bracelet station (we have a full guide on setting one up)
- Decorated picture frames with a photo printed on the spot
- Tie-dye pillowcases or tote bags they make themselves
- Small painted canvases from a mini art station
- Pressed flower bookmarks made during the party
Packaging Makes a Bigger Difference Than You'd Think
A three dollar item in a kraft bag with a ribbon and a name tag feels like a ten dollar item. Presentation is part of the gift. A simple bag, some tissue paper, and a label with her name on it is all it takes to make something feel like it was made for her specifically.
Time-saving tip: Put the favors together the week before the party, not the morning of. You will be calmer, everything will look better, and there will still be time to fix anything that feels off.
What to Skip
A few things consistently end up in the trash or cause problems: whistles and noisemakers, candy that melts in a warm car, anything with small pieces that scatter immediately, and generic plastic items with no connection to the party.
If you are not sure whether something belongs in the bag, ask yourself: would I be happy if my daughter came home with this? That is usually the clearest answer.
Our party boxes come with favors already sorted. Pair with our teepee rentals and you have the whole night covered. Start at Sleepover Club.
Keep Reading
Take the Guesswork Out of It
Our party boxes come with curated themed items and extras so you have one less thing to plan from scratch.